What Parents Should Know About the New York Juvenile Justice System
When a minor gets caught up in the legal system, parents can feel anxious and overwhelmed. Understanding the New York Juvenile Justice System is essential to protect your child’s rights and navigate the process effectively. Here’s a comprehensive guide to help parents in Orange County and the Hudson Valley approach this challenging situation with confidence. For legal advice and representation tailored to your particular situation, contact Dupée & Monroe, P.C., to visit with a skilled and experienced Goshen criminal defense attorney.
1. Age Categories and Processing Courts
New York classifies youth offenders differently depending on age and the nature of the offense. Critically, not all cases go to criminal court.
-
Juvenile Delinquent: Children ages 7 to 12 who commit serious offenses or ages 12 to 15 who commit acts that would be criminal if committed by an adult are handled in Family Court. Cases are confidential, and outcomes may include supervision, treatment, or placement.
-
Juvenile Offender: Ages 13–15 charged with serious or violent felonies appear in the Youth Part of Supreme or County Court, potentially facing harsher penalties, but still with some protections and possible transfer to Family Court.
-
Adolescent Offender: Ages 16–17 charged with felonies are tried in the Youth Part. That said, many cases, especially less serious ones, may be transferred to Family Court, aligning with rehabilitative goals.
The Raise the Age law, phased in from 2018 to 2019, removed the automatic adult classification for most 16– and 17-year-olds, which supports age-appropriate treatment and placement.
2. Rights During Arrest and Questioning
Parents should know that mandatory parental notification is required when a 16- or 17-year-old is arrested—without exception. Interrogations must occur in age-appropriate settings, with a parent or guardian present to waive Miranda rights if necessary. Legal representation is also guaranteed. Youth must have an attorney, even if parents cannot afford one, and counsel must be present at critical stages, including hearings and questioning.
3. How Cases Proceed and Possible Outcomes
Fact-Finding Hearing
In Family Court, cases go before a judge (without a jury). Evidence must show beyond a reasonable doubt that the child committed the alleged act. If not proven, the case is dismissed.
Dispositional Hearing
If the court determines the child committed the offense, a separate hearing is scheduled. This hearing examines the child’s home and school behavior and may include mental health evaluations. The judge then decides between supervision, counseling, probation, or placement in a facility, always aiming for rehabilitation over punishment.
Adolescent and Juvenile Offenders handled in Youth Parts may face more severe penalties, but they can also be considered for alternatives like Youthful Offender status, which seals the record upon sentencing.
4. Facilities and Placement
Youth delinquency placements are handled sensitively. Juvenile Delinquents typically stay in community-based or close-to-home placement programs run by OCFS, not adult jails. Adolescent Offenders, meanwhile, are detained in specialized juvenile facilities, never co-located with adults. Sentences under one year may be served in these facilities, while longer terms go to OCFS/DOCCS-adult-designated branches with safeguards.
5. Sealing and Youthful Offender Status
To protect a youth’s future, New York allows designations such as Youthful Offender status and sealing of court records. Youthful Offender status, which can be granted at sentencing, ensures that no criminal record remains. Youths aged 14–18 may be eligible depending on the case. Likewise, record sealing is generally available after the youth turns 18 and maintains a clean record for ten years, although records of violent or serious crimes may be excluded from sealing.
6. Prevention and Support Programs
New York emphasizes rehabilitation, not punishment. Programs such as the Close to Home Initiative allow youth to serve placements near community and family. In addition, diversion parts, designed for 16- and 17-year-olds, offer alternatives like community service, civic goal-setting, and counseling in lieu of conventional sentencing. Community-based early intervention, including mentoring, tutoring, and counseling, boosts protective factors and reduces delinquency risk.
7. Why Parents Need Legal Support
Given these complexities, parents should consider:
- Immediate legal counsel when youth are arrested to safeguard their rights during interrogation and court appearances.
- Advocacy for rehabilitation-based outcomes, leveraging diversion, counseling, and placement options.
- Awareness of sealing and Youthful Offender options to protect a child’s record.
At Dupée & Monroe, P.C., in Goshen, we provide compassionate, experienced advocacy for families dealing with juvenile delinquency matters in Orange County and the mid-Hudson Valley. We guide you through Family Court, help invoke juvenile protections, and work to ensure the best long-term outcome for your child.
Contact Dupée & Monroe, P.C., Today
New York’s juvenile justice system prioritizes rehabilitating young people rather than punishing them. Parents must be informed and proactive—understanding age classifications, court processes, rights, and available support services—to ensure their child’s rights and future are protected. Getting legal advice and representation immediately is the best way to help your child.
Contact Dupée & Monroe, P.C. today for a confidential consultation if your child has become involved in the juvenile justice system. We’re here to guide you every step of the way.
