Eligibility and Process for Sealing a Criminal Record in New York

A criminal conviction can continue to affect a person’s life long after a sentence has been completed. A criminal record can create obstacles when applying for employment, housing, professional licenses, and educational opportunities. However, New York law provides several ways for eligible individuals to limit public access to certain criminal records.
The rules depend on the type of conviction, the person’s criminal history, and the time that has passed since the case ended. Some records qualify for automatic sealing, while others require an application to the court. The Goshen criminal defense attorneys at Dupée & Monroe, P.C. help people facing criminal matters in Orange County and the mid-Hudson Valley, including individuals seeking to understand their options after a conviction.
What Does It Mean to Seal a Criminal Record in New York?
Sealing a criminal record does not erase the underlying conviction. Instead, it restricts public access to records associated with the case. Depending on the legal basis for sealing, the restrictions can cover court records, police records, and other criminal history information.
Sealed records are not inaccessible to everyone. Certain law enforcement agencies, government authorities, and other legally authorized entities may still be able to obtain information about a sealed case. For example, sealing under New York law does not necessarily prevent immigration authorities from accessing a conviction.
New York generally uses sealing rather than expungement for criminal convictions. Expungement treats a conviction as though it no longer exists for legal purposes, while sealing limits who can see the record. Certain marijuana-related convictions are subject to separate expungement provisions.
Which Criminal Records Can Be Sealed Automatically?
Some New York criminal records are sealed without requiring the person to file an application. Under Criminal Procedure Law § 160.50, cases that end in a favorable disposition generally qualify for automatic sealing. Examples include cases resulting in an acquittal, dismissal, or certain other outcomes in which the charges are terminated in the defendant’s favor.
Certain violations and traffic infractions receive partial sealing under separate provisions. These rules differ from the sealing process for misdemeanor and felony convictions.
New York’s Clean Slate Act also provides for automatic sealing of many eligible misdemeanor and felony convictions. Under this law, eligible misdemeanor convictions generally qualify for sealing after three years, while eligible felony convictions generally qualify after eight years. The waiting period runs from sentencing or release from incarceration, whichever is later.
To qualify under the Clean Slate Act, a person cannot have a pending misdemeanor or felony case or remain on probation, parole, or post-release supervision. A new conviction before the record is sealed can restart the applicable waiting period. Certain offenses are excluded, including sex offenses and most non-drug-related Class A felonies.
The Clean Slate Act took effect on November 16, 2024. However, New York’s court system has until November 16, 2027, to complete the process of identifying and sealing all eligible records. Individuals who believe their convictions qualify should understand that the statutory waiting period and the completion of the statewide implementation process are separate considerations.
Who Qualifies to Apply for Sealing?
New York Criminal Procedure Law § 160.59 provides a separate process through which a person can ask a court to seal certain misdemeanor and felony convictions. Unlike Clean Slate sealing, this process requires an application and a judge’s approval.
To qualify, an applicant must have no more than two eligible criminal convictions, with no more than one felony. The convictions can include two misdemeanors or one misdemeanor and one felony. Certain convictions arising from the same criminal transaction may be treated as a single conviction for eligibility purposes.
At least 10 years must have passed since the imposition of the sentence for the most recent conviction or the person’s latest release from incarceration, whichever is later. Time spent incarcerated after the conviction can extend the waiting period. The applicant generally must not have any new criminal convictions or a pending criminal case.
Not every offense qualifies. Excluded offenses include many violent felonies, sex offenses, homicide offenses, and Class A felonies. A person required to register as a sex offender is also ineligible under this provision. Federal and out-of-state convictions cannot be sealed through a New York CPL § 160.59 application.
Meeting the basic eligibility requirements does not guarantee approval. The court has discretion to grant or deny the application after considering the circumstances of the convictions, the applicant’s conduct since the offenses, evidence of rehabilitation, and other relevant factors.
How Do You Apply to Seal a Criminal Conviction?
A person seeking sealing under CPL § 160.59 must file an application with the appropriate court. The process involves gathering records, preparing sworn documents, notifying the prosecutor, and submitting the application for judicial review.
The applicant needs a Certificate of Disposition for each conviction they want sealed. This document identifies the outcome of the criminal case and the sentence imposed. The applicant must then complete the sealing application, which includes a sworn statement explaining why the court should grant the request.
Evidence of rehabilitation can strengthen an application. Depending on the circumstances, useful documentation might include employment records, educational achievements, community service, treatment-program completion certificates, or letters from employers and community members. The goal is to give the judge a meaningful picture of the applicant’s conduct and accomplishments since the conviction.
The applicant must also serve a copy of the application and supporting documents on the appropriate District Attorney’s Office. The original papers are then filed with the court where the most serious conviction was entered. If the convictions occurred in different counties, the relevant prosecutors must receive notice.
The District Attorney can oppose the application. If the prosecutor objects, the court generally must hold a hearing to consider the parties’ evidence and arguments. If the application is unopposed, a hearing is not necessarily required. The judge ultimately decides whether sealing is appropriate.
Because the application involves eligibility requirements, court records, and procedural steps, mistakes or missing documentation can delay the process or lead to denial. An attorney can review the criminal history, identify potentially eligible convictions, and prepare the application and supporting evidence.
Can Drug-Related Convictions Be Sealed?
New York also provides a conditional sealing process under Criminal Procedure Law § 160.58 for certain drug-related convictions. In qualifying cases, a person who has successfully completed an eligible judicial diversion program or certain substance-use treatment programs can ask the court to seal specified convictions.
This provision has its own eligibility requirements and does not apply to every drug offense or treatment history. The type of conviction, the program completed, and the applicable statutory conditions all matter. Someone who does not qualify under CPL § 160.59 may still want to determine whether this separate provision offers a possible route to relief.
What If You Do Not Qualify for Criminal Record Sealing?
A person who does not qualify for sealing may have other options. A Certificate of Relief from Disabilities or a Certificate of Good Conduct can help restore certain rights and address some legal barriers associated with a conviction. These certificates do not seal the criminal record, but they can provide meaningful relief in employment, licensing, and other contexts.
The appropriate option depends on the person’s convictions, sentence, criminal history, and goals. It is important to review the available remedies rather than assume that an old conviction will remain an unavoidable obstacle.
Discuss Your Criminal Record Sealing Options With Dupée & Monroe
New York’s criminal record sealing laws offer opportunities for some people to move forward without having an eligible conviction remain publicly accessible. However, the rules differ depending on whether the record qualifies for automatic sealing, requires a court application, or falls under a separate statutory process.
Dupée & Monroe, P.C., represents individuals facing criminal matters in Goshen, Orange County, and throughout the Hudson Valley. If you want to determine whether your criminal record qualifies for sealing, contact the firm to discuss your history, review the applicable eligibility requirements, and understand the steps that may be available.